What happens when you take the structure of a classic modern “Western” like First Blood and drop it into a world where no one agrees on what’s real?
In this episode, Jake explores Eddington as a deliberate genre reimagining of First Blood, tracing how Ari Aster uses the same Western engine—outsider versus town, escalating indignities, and an eventual eruption of violence—but produces very different results.
Through deep analysis of Eddington’s opening sequence, core thematic scenes, and its critically divisive final act, Jake breaks down how theme reshapes character alignment, dialogue, escalation, and structure—and why the film ultimately abandons realism altogether.
By the end, you’ll see how Eddington is not just an update of First Blood, but a powerful lesson in genre adaptation—how letting theme drive character, action, dialogue, and structure can produce stories that resist simplicity and reflect the world we’re actually living in.
You’ll Learn
° A structural comparison of Eddington and First Blood as modern “Westerns” built on a similar narrative engine.
° How Eddington’s opening sequence functions as a twisted homage to First Blood—and the vital role opening images play in framing a complicated film.
° How small, specific visual choices turn exposition into character-driven storytelling.
° How mirrored moments across a script reveal escalation without explanation or commentary.
° How Eddington and First Blood use the same pattern of escalating indignities to drive their protagonists toward an “aria of violence”.
° How Eddington uses key scenes to align us with Joe’s problematic perception of events—and make us fall in love with him even if we disagree with his politics.
° Deep analysis of Eddington’s core thematic scenes.
° A close breakdown of how dialogue scenes in Eddington escalate conflict rather than resolve it, as characters talk past each other while operating inside incompatible realities.
° Why the film’s final act abandons realism—and how that choice grows directly out of the film’s thematic design.
° How to explore charged, uncomfortable ideas without offering the audience a clean moral roadmap.
° Why refusing to make stories “simple and neat” can be a powerful and intentional craft choice.
🎧 LISTEN NOW to learn how letting theme drive structure can unlock deeper characters, sharper scenes, and more honest screenwriting.
Join Jake for free every Thursday night at Thursday Night Writes, RSVP here
and check all of our classes!
